Hey Lauren, Phia here, your personalized shopping assistant. I added some picks for you below.
Chosen With Lauren In Mind

Why this edit and not a generic one
Eight pairs instead of a wall of shoes. The mix leans quiet shapes that hold up past one season, which is the throughline in what you gravitate toward, and Zimmermann fits right in. Check heel height and how far each one walks before the label.
Shoes

Marvi Pump 95
Zimmermann

Ashbey Heel
Steve Madden
Sylvia Extra Wide Calf Pointed Toe High Heel Boots
Sam Edelman

Carly Satin Sandals
CULT GAIA

BECKETT BALLET FLAT - NATURAL
Cult Gaia

Belara Appliqued Metallic Leather Wedge Sandals
Zimmermann
Margeaux Mesh Pumps
Sam Edelman
Women's The Almond Mesh Slingback Flats
Rothy's
What this ties into right now
This edit rides what is moving in shoes on Phia right now. The same instinct runs through Zimmermann, Sam Edelman and Steve Madden here: recognisable shape, quiet finish, nothing that dates in a season. The versions I picked are the plainer ones in each label's line rather than the loudest.









