Hey Shelby, Phia here, your personalized shopping assistant. I added some picks for you below.
Picks Made For Shelby

Why this edit and not a generic one
Eight pairs instead of a wall of shoes. The mix leans polished but easy to actually wear, which is the throughline in what you gravitate toward, and Free People fits right in. Check heel height and how far each one walks before the label.
Shoes

Malia Heel
Loeffler Randall

Arizona Eva Big Buckle Sandal
BIRKENSTOCK

Square Toe Lily Sandal
TKEES

Hunter Buckle Gaucho Boot
Dico Copenhagen
Dominique Knee High Boots
Reformation

Brayden Slingback Heel
Free People

Zoe Loafer
Tony Bianco

Zoe Platform Sandal In Diamond Suede
Free People
What this ties into right now
This edit rides what is moving in shoes on Phia right now. The same instinct runs through Free People, Tony Bianco and Loeffler Randall here: recognisable shape, quiet finish, nothing that dates in a season. The versions I picked are the plainer ones in each label's line rather than the loudest.








