Best Black Scrunchies

Best Black Scrunchies

A black scrunchie is a small practical decision that can make a ponytail feel intentional. These picks move from velvet and Re-Nylon to silk, with shapes for low ponytails, loose buns and the kind of fall layers you already wear.

At Mansur Gavriel's Fall 2017 New York Fashion Week runway, models' air-dried lengths were tied into low-slung ponytails with jet-black ties made from vintage fabrics. Vogue's account describes the low ponytails, and that unfussy finish still makes sense to me.

 

A black scrunchie is useful because it can disappear into the routine or quietly finish the look, depending on whether it is velvet, silk or something with more shape. With a wool coat, knits or a leather jacket, a low ponytail feels like a choice instead of a hair emergency.

 

My test is to pull your hair back once, then check whether the tie feels comfortable and stays put when you turn your head. If you stop noticing it, that is a good sign.

Mood board for black scrunchie: street-style photos and close-ups of pieces from this edit
Best Black Scrunchies

Velvet and Re-Nylon

Alexandre de Paris's Romi Velvet Scrunchie brings velvet to the low ponytail, Prada's Re-Nylon Scrunchie gives the group a different material, and OLAH's Cherry Silk Velvet Hair Scrunchie names both silk and velvet. A black scrunchie is at its best when it works with the outfit rather than competing with it. I would wear the velvet option with a wool coat and a low ponytail, then save the silk velvet one for a knit and a looser bun. The Re-Nylon name feels right for a more practical day. Keep a few face-framing pieces free if you want the finish to feel less severe.

Collage of street-style photos of women wearing black scrunchie, scattered and overlapping on white
A good ponytail tie, no speech required.

Skinny Ties for Everyday Hair

Slip's Pure Silk Back to Basics Assorted Skinny Scrunchies Set, 4 Pack and Slip's Skinny Silk Scrunchies Set of 4 both name silk and a slim shape. Gimme Beauty's Fine Fit Hair Bands give you a simpler band option in the same grid. For a black scrunchie, skinny does not have to mean invisible; it can just mean the ponytail stays neat under a hood or collar. I would use one for a low ponytail with a chunky knit, especially when a big scrunchie would press against the back of a coat. The sets also make sense if you like to keep a spare in your bag.

A Triangle, a Ribbon, and Silk

Prada's Triangle Velvet Scrunchie gives the shape a little geometry, Slip's Pure Silk 4-Pack Skinny Scrunchies names its material and slim profile, and Alexandre de Paris's Isild Velvet Ribbon Hair Tie brings ribbon into the mix. A black scrunchie can be a quiet detail, but these names give you a few ways to change the texture. I would wear the triangle version with hair half-up and a fine knit, then use the ribbon tie for a low ponytail under a leather jacket. Keep the rest of the hair soft rather than pulled tight. That small difference makes the same basic outfit feel less automatic.

Padded Silk for a Soft Bun

Drowsy Sleep Co.'s Silk Padded Scrunchie names a padded shape, SILKSILKY's Pure Silk 3-Pack Large Scrunchies gives you a larger silk option, and Alexandre de Paris's Ponytail Holder is the plainspoken one here. For a black scrunchie day, I like this group for a loose bun that can survive a long afternoon without looking too arranged. Try the padded version with a soft knit, or use one of the larger options when your hair needs more room. The ponytail holder makes sense when you want less volume at the tie. A wool coat over the top keeps the whole thing easy.

Skinny, Shiny, or Just Enough

Drowsy Sleep Co.'s Skinny Scrunchie Set returns to a slim shape, Lovers and Friends' Amira Scrunchie keeps its name simple, and Ettika's Shiny Square Hair Tie offers the most specific shape in the group. A black scrunchie gives all three a place in the same fall rotation, from a low bun with a wool coat to a ponytail under a leather jacket. I would use the skinny set for a half-up style and save the square tie for a plain knit. What I would skip is stacking several ties together; one is enough to make the point. Then the hair can look finished without looking fussed over.

Pick the Tie for the Coat

My rule of thumb is to match the scrunchie's volume to the collar: a skinny tie under a high coat collar, a softer padded shape with an open neckline. A black scrunchie should make the ponytail easier, then let you forget about it.