Coach vs Kate Spade Bag Charms, Compared by Price

Coach vs Kate Spade Bag Charms, Compared by Price

Sixteen charms from Coach and Kate Spade in four price bands from $45 to $195, to see which brand gives you more at each step.

Two ways to do a bag charm

Coach and Kate Spade are the two names most people reach for when they want a designer charm that is not a Louis Vuitton price. I put sixteen of their current charms on one chart, Coach on the left and Kate Spade on the right, with price running top to bottom from $45 to $195. Kate Spade starts a little higher at $48 and tops out at $129, while Coach goes up to $195.

Comparison chart of Coach and Kate Spade bag charms by price from forty-five to one hundred ninety-five dollars

Coach: animals and shearling

Coach charms are mostly animals and fruit, and the price follows the material. The DIY cherry is $45, the puffy bear is $55, the frog and strawberry are $75, the cherry and bear are $95, and the shearling Teddy and Fuzzy are $195. Coach is the one to pick if you want the charm to look like a tiny version of a leather bag.

Kate Spade: snacks and characters

Kate Spade leans on food and critters, a cupcake and chocolate strawberry at $48, a pizza and fish at $78, a Teddi Bear and hedgehog at $98, and a Hello Kitty and coffee cup at $129. They are enamel and leather and feel more like jewelry than toys. If you want something to match a spring bag, this is the shelf.

How I would choose

I would buy Coach for plush and Kate Spade for enamel and keep the budget under $100 for the first one. The overlap from $75 to $98 is where the two compare best.