Sixteen charms from Coach and Kate Spade in four price bands from $45 to $195, to see which brand gives you more at each step.

Coach vs Kate Spade Bag Charms, Compared by Price
Two ways to do a bag charm
Coach and Kate Spade are the two names most people reach for when they want a designer charm that is not a Louis Vuitton price. I put sixteen of their current charms on one chart, Coach on the left and Kate Spade on the right, with price running top to bottom from $45 to $195. Kate Spade starts a little higher at $48 and tops out at $129, while Coach goes up to $195.

Coach: animals and shearling
Coach charms are mostly animals and fruit, and the price follows the material. The DIY cherry is $45, the puffy bear is $55, the frog and strawberry are $75, the cherry and bear are $95, and the shearling Teddy and Fuzzy are $195. Coach is the one to pick if you want the charm to look like a tiny version of a leather bag.

DIY Cherry Charm
Coach

Puffy Bear Bag Charm
Coach

Strawberry Bag Charm
Coach

Frog Bag Charm
Coach

Cherry Bag Charm
Coach

Bear Bag Charm
Coach

Teddy Bear Bag Charm in Shearling
Coach

Fuzzy Bag Charm in Shearling
Coach

Butterfly Bag Charm
Coach

Crystal Cherry Bag Charm
Coach

Smudge Bear Bag Charm
Jellycat

Gussied Up Teddy Bag Charm
Susan Alexandra
Kate Spade: snacks and characters
Kate Spade leans on food and critters, a cupcake and chocolate strawberry at $48, a pizza and fish at $78, a Teddi Bear and hedgehog at $98, and a Hello Kitty and coffee cup at $129. They are enamel and leather and feel more like jewelry than toys. If you want something to match a spring bag, this is the shelf.

Charmed Cupcake Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Charmed Chocolate Strawberry Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Charmed NYC Pizza Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Critters Finn Fish Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Monsters Teddi Bear Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Critters Stevie Hedgehog Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Hello Kitty Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Charmed Coffee Cup Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Critters Frannie Flamingo Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Dog Dangle Bag Charm
Kate Spade

Charmed Rose Bag Charm
Kate Spade New York

Woven Fish Leather Bag Charm
Madewell
How I would choose
I would buy Coach for plush and Kate Spade for enamel and keep the budget under $100 for the first one. The overlap from $75 to $98 is where the two compare best.






