Goldbelly Food Gifts: Pies, Pizza and Regional Classics by Mail

Goldbelly Food Gifts: Pies, Pizza and Regional Classics by Mail

Goldbelly was founded in 2013 so beloved regional food could travel beyond its hometown. These are the pies, pizzas, sandwiches and gift boxes I would send for the holidays.

Why the Best Food in America Used to Stay Home

Everyone has a food they cannot get where they live now. A pizza from the town they grew up in, a pie from a roadside bakery, the barbecue a friend still talks about. Goldbelly was built around that feeling. Founder and CEO Joe Ariel says he started by calling favorite food spots in Nashville, Memphis and Buffalo to ask whether they would ship, and the first boxes made the idea real. The company was founded in 2013, and its stated mission is to make the love of great food travel to people wherever they are.

 

It has grown into a marketplace of more than 1,000 restaurants, pitmasters, bakeries and regional artisans across all 50 states, and Goldbelly notes that many of those partners had never sold beyond their own communities. Its SafeShip logistics handles perishable food, which is the unglamorous reason any of this works. This year Goldbelly was named the Official Marketplace for Taste of America 250. I think of it as the easiest thoughtful gift there is, so I sorted my picks the way I shop: pies and desserts for Thanksgiving, regional legends for the person who misses home, and brunch and gift boxes for hosts.

Pies and Desserts for the Thanksgiving Table

If you are hosting and do not bake, this is your grid. The Elegant Farmer's apple pie is baked in a paper bag, which gives it a crackly sugared top you cannot fake at home. Red Truck Bakery sends a traditional pecan pie, and Commander's Palace sends its own pecan pie from New Orleans. Royer's Round Top Cafe makes the Texas Trash Pie, a gooey, everything-in-it pie that always disappears first.

 

The PieCaken is the showstopper: pie layers baked inside cake, stacked high, the dessert that gets photographed before anyone cuts it. The pumpkin cheesecake from the Nuns of New Skete is the quieter classic for anyone who finds pumpkin pie too plain. O&H Danish Bakery's apple kringle is the breakfast-on-Thanksgiving-morning move, and Ina Garten's carrot cake is for the table that wants something besides pie. If you are setting up the kitchen too, I gathered fall kitchen essentials here.

 

Order timing tip: book shipping for the Monday or Tuesday before. What I would skip: ordering three pies for six people. Two plus the kringle is plenty.

Regional Legends for Whoever Misses Home

This is the grid I send to friends who moved away. Lou Malnati's deep-dish pizzas are Chicago in a box, and John's of Bleecker Street sends the thin, charred New York slice that people line up for in the West Village. Pat's King of Steaks ships its original Philly cheesesteak as a kit you finish at home, which is the only way a cheesesteak survives the trip.

 

Langer's #19 is the Los Angeles pastrami sandwich people fly in for, and Chaps sends its Baltimore pit beef. For barbecue, Central BBQ ships Memphis ribs and pulled pork for four, and Cooper's Old Time Pit Bar-B-Que sends a whole Texas brisket that will feed a crowd of ten to twelve. The Commander's Palace holiday dinner for four is the one I would book for a small Christmas with no one cooking.

 

A gifting note I learned the hard way: send a sandwich kit to someone who likes assembling food and a finished dinner to someone who does not. What I would skip: the full brisket for a household of two. It is a party gift, so save it for the friend who hosts.

Brunch Boxes and Gifts for Hosts

When I am a guest for a holiday weekend, I would rather send breakfast than bring wine. Essa Bagel's New York bagel brunch for six arrives with bagels, lox and cream cheese, and Biscuit Love's brunch box brings a taste of Nashville to a slow Sunday. The Model Bakery sampler from Napa is the one I would send to a friend who loves a bakery more than a restaurant.

 

For cheese, Jasper Hill Farm's Raw Milk Rockstars is a box of Vermont cheeses for someone who likes a board, and Sweet Grass Dairy sends its Georgia best sellers. Blackberry Farm's Taste of the Farm is the gift for a host who loves Tennessee and nice jars. Junior's mini cheesecakes are a New York classic that kids and grandparents agree on, and the Vosges Haut-Chocolat comfort food trio is for the chocolate person in your life. I put together more ideas for thanking a host in my hostess gifts edit.

 

Time it to arrive the day before you do, so breakfast is waiting. What I would skip: perishable boxes to a house that will be empty for the weekend.