A nyx blush comes in three very different textures, from the buttery pressed powder of Buttermelt to the juicy Fat Cheeks liquid and the Wonder Stick. Here is how I would choose between them, and which shades from other brands sit next to each one.
NYX Blush: Buttermelt, Fat Cheeks and Wonder Stick Shades

NYX started in Los Angeles in 1999, when Toni Ko founded it at 25 with a line of makeup pencils, and L'Oréal announced it would acquire the brand in June 2014. That background in professional makeup artistry is still in the DNA, which is why a nyx blush tends to be strongly pigmented and easy to control.
The one to start with is the NYX Buttermelt Blush. It is a pressed powder infused with shea butter, mango butter and almond butter, so it feels buttery and blends smoothly, and the brand says it wears up to 12 hours and resists fade and transfer. My Butta Half, Butta Together and Sooner The Butta are all in this grid. If you like a nyx buttermelt blush, these are the powders I would put beside it.
Haus Labs Color Fuse in French Rosette is a neutral rose with fermented arnica and squalane, talc free and natural in finish. Saie SuperSuede in Grazie is a bright berry baked powder. Kosas Blush is Life in Butterflies is a cool baby pink baked with squalane and hyaluronic acid. Hung Vanngo Beauty Very Beautiful in Full Circle is a berry pink with a cloud matte finish and shea butter. Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin Flushed in Jubilee is a soft terracotta for cheeks and lips.
A quick test: swirl your brush once, tap off the extra, and sweep it on. Buttery powders are pigmented, so build slowly.

NYX Buttermelt and other buttery powder blushes

Buttermelt Blush in My Butta Half
NYX

Buttermelt Blush in Butta Together
NYX

Buttermelt Blush in Sooner The Butta
NYX

Color Fuse Talc-Free Blush Powder With Fermented Arnica in French Rosette
Haus Labs

SuperSuede Radiant Talc-Free Baked Powder Blush in Grazie
Saie

Blush is Life Baked Talc-Free Dimensional + Brightening Blush in Butterflies
Kosas

Very Beautiful Matte Velvet Blush in Full Circle
HUNG VANNGO BEAUTY

Yummy Skin Blurring Balm Powder Flushed - Matte Color for Cheek & Lip in Jubilee
Danessa Myricks Beauty
Juicy liquids with a dewy finish
Fat Cheeks is where NYX goes juicy. NYX Fat Cheeks Juicy Liquid Blush in Papaya Plump and Peach Plunge is a hydrating liquid with a dewy finish, and the brand describes it as its first dewy liquid blush of its kind. Papaya and peach are both warm-leaning names, so I would try them on bare skin or over a light base.
Fenty Beauty Shake N' Play in Bow'Peep is a petal pink that builds from one dot for a blurred look to two or more for bold, with a squish-tip sponge applicator and up to 12 hours of wear. REFY Water Blush in Lychee is a bright pink with warm tones in a cushion compact, made with ceramides. Saie Dew Blush in Poppy is a bright coral that comes with a doe foot applicator. ciele blush and PROTECT in Elodie is a hot coral liquid with mineral SPF 50. Surratt Artistique Liquid Blush in Cantaloup and Rodial Blush Drops finish the grid, and I would check the shade in person on both.
Pairing tip: dot liquid blush on the cheeks and blend up toward the temple with your fingertips, then press a little onto the eyelids so the color feels connected.
What I would skip: layering a liquid blush over a thick, matte foundation that has already set. It lifts and streaks, so apply it while the base is still fresh.
Juicy liquid blushes like NYX Fat Cheeks

Fat Cheeks Juicy Liquid Blush in Papaya Plump
NYX

Fat Cheeks Juicy Liquid Blush in Peach Plunge
NYX

Shake N' Play Liquid Blush in Bow'Peep
Fenty Beauty by Rihanna

Water Blush Liquid Cushion with Ceramides in Lychee
REFY

Dew Blush Liquid Cream Blush in Poppy
Saie

blush & PROTECT SPF 50+ liquid blush in Elodie
ciele

Artistique Liquid Blush in Cantaloup
Surratt

Blush Drops
Rodial
Cream sticks that melt in
Sticks are the easy answer for mornings, and the Wonder Stick is the NYX answer. NYX Wonder Stick Blush in Coral and Deep Peach is a dual-ended cream blush stick that melts into skin. Coral and Deep Peach both lean warm, so I would try it on a bare cheek first.
Bobbi Brown Skin Enhancer Blush Stick in Crushed Fuchsia is a rich cool pink for cheeks and lips with hyaluronic acid spheres. Makeup by Mario Soft Pop in Pale Petal is a soft pink stick with a built-in brush. LYS Beauty Higher Standard in Outgoing is a watermelon pink with medium coverage. KJH.brand Soft Smudge in Soft Orchid is a deep fuchsia cream-to-powder multi-stick with a soft matte finish. Dolce&Gabbana Cherry Glaze Bar in Smitten Pink is a waterproof fuchsia stick with a glossy, glazed look. Neen Going Rouge in Shake is a cream for cheeks and lips. Ogee Sculpted Cream Blush Stick in Topaz is a matte rosy peach with a radiant finish.
How to wear it: stamp the stick on the apples and blend outward with a fingertip. One swipe is a tint, two is a flush.
What I would skip: a deep fuchsia stick on very sheer skin in daylight. Use one light stamp there, or choose a soft pink like Pale Petal.
Cream sticks like NYX Wonder Stick

Wonder Stick Blush in Coral and Deep Peach
NYX

Skin Enhancer Blush Stick in Crushed Fuchsia
Bobbi Brown

Soft Pop Cream Blush Stick in Pale Petal
MAKEUP BY MARIO

Higher Standard Cream Glow Blush Sticks in Outgoing
LYS Beauty

Soft Smudge Lip & Cheek Cream Blush Multistick in Soft Orchid
KJH.brand by Katie Jane Hughes

Cherry Glaze Bar 24H Lasting Glow & Waterproof Cream Blush Stick with Vegan Collagen in 02 Smitten Pink
Dolce&Gabbana

Going Rouge Cream Blush & Lip in Shake
Neen

Sculpted Cream Blush Stick in Topaz
Ogee
Picking your NYX texture
Choose the texture that fits your morning. If you like a soft, blurred cheek, Buttermelt is the one. If you like skin that looks a little juicy, Fat Cheeks is the pick. If you want speed, the Wonder Stick lives in a bag pocket. Then match the shade to your undertone: cool pinks like Butterflies and Crushed Fuchsia suit cool skin, while corals and peaches like Peach Plunge and Topaz warm up olive and deeper skin. Apply color a little higher than you think, blend it until the edge is gone, and keep everything else quiet.






