Straw hat options here range from broad sun brims to boaters, buckets and ribbon-tied shapes. I would decide by crown depth, brim width and how the hat will travel.

Straw hat: From Toquilla Weaving to a Paris Boater
The brim has a backstory
At the Musée des Arts décoratifs in Paris, a plaited straw boater by Caroline Reboux is dated 1900. The Saint Louis Art Museum notes that boaters moved from boating and yachting into city life in the 1880s and 1890s, with women taking them up too. Straw hat sounds like a simple material label, but that boater's flat crown, wide brim and red piping were already a whole attitude.
UNESCO's account of Ecuadorian toquilla weaving makes the same point from another angle: palm fiber is prepared, then woven into the crown and brim, with the work taking from a day to eight months depending on quality and finesse. Not every style here is toquilla, so I would treat straw, raffia and paper as different materials, not interchangeable labels.
For a broad-brimmed choice, Eric Javits's Sea La Vie has a 5 1/4-inch brim and rounded crown; Janessa Leoné's Waverly puts a 5-inch brim on a deep pinched crown and is packable. Sunshine Tienda's Irma brings stripes to palm straw, while the Carolina's blue whipstitch band is quieter. Favorite Daughter's Straw Favorite has a deep crown and gently flared brim, and Brixton's Helena balances a tall crown with packability. I would compare brim width, crown depth and the available head size before deciding which profile belongs with my summer clothes.


Wide-brim straw hats

Sea La Vie Straw Sun Hat
Eric Javits

Irma Palm Straw Sun Hat
Sunshine Tienda

Waverly Wide Brim Packable Straw Hat
Janessa Leoné

The Straw Favorite Sun Hat
Favorite Daughter

Carolina Palm Straw Sun Hat
Sunshine Tienda

Helena Packable Straw Sun Hat
Brixton

Herringbone Weave Panama Hat
Vince

Redwood Straw Hat
Freya
Straw boater and bucket hats
A boater's flat crown makes the hat feel more graphic than a floppy sun brim. The V&A traces the style from summer sport into 1890s city wear, so I would make the crown-and-band combination the deciding detail. Lack of Color's Spencer has a black grosgrain band and a 3.5-inch brim; rag & bone's raffia version swaps that ribbon for a braided cord. Gigi Burris Millinery's Marion keeps the band tonal, while Angela & William's Wheat Straw Skimmer has a striped one and a compact brim.
Among the buckets, Vitamin A's Tulum is handwoven raffia, San Diego Hat's Weekend is a soft green option, Brixton's Ellee has contrasting bands and an openwork brim, and Lack of Color's Reef leaves the edge softly raw. I would wear a flat-crown style with an open-collar shirt or clean sleeveless dress, leaving one strong line around the face. What I would skip: a crown that seems too shallow for the stated head size; check the size range and fit notes before choosing a ribbon.



Spencer Straw Boater Hat
Lack of Color

Raffia Straw Boater Hat
rag & bone

Marion Woven Straw Boater Hat
Gigi Burris Millinery

Wheat Straw Skimmer Boater Hat
Angela & William

Tulum Straw Bucket Hat
Vitamin A

Weekend Straw Bucket Hat
San Diego Hat

Ellee Festival Straw Bucket Hat
Brixton

Reef Straw Bucket Hat
Lack of Color
Raffia and woven straw hats
UNESCO's description of Ecuadorian toquilla hats says the fiber comes from a coastal palm and the weaving can take from one day to eight months, depending on finesse. That tradition is not a blanket label for every raffia style here, and I would look closely at the material and construction notes rather than infer origin from color.
The rag & bone Woven Raffia Bucket is a simple starting point; Lack of Color's Raffia Cowboy changes the silhouette with a sculpted crown; Faherty's broad Raffia Sun Hat is the most sun-forward. Janessa Leoné's Felix uses hand-crocheted raffia and a 3 1/4-inch brim, while Helen Kaminski's Provence 12 is rollable and packable. Haven Well Within adds an interior fit adjustment under a 6 1/4-inch brim; Eugenia Kim's Yuki brings UPF 50+ to a bucket shape, and the Jonah Stripe is hand-crocheted in natural and black. I would pair the woven surfaces with smooth cotton, then check crown depth, inner band and the brim edge for an even finish. What I would skip: a broad brim that takes over when the rest of the outfit already has a loud pattern.



Woven Raffia Bucket Hat
rag & bone

Raffia Cowboy Hat
Lack of Color

Raffia Sun Hat
Faherty

Felix Crochet Raffia Bucket Hat
Janessa Leoné

Provence 12 Packable Raffia Hat
Helen Kaminski

Raffia Sun Hat
Haven Well Within

Yuki UPF 50+ Packable Raffia Bucket Hat
Eugenia Kim

Jonah Stripe Packable Straw Bucket Sun Hat
Eugenia Kim
Straw hats with a ribbon or tie
Trim is a small decision that can do the work of a print. A V&A example of an 1890s boater pairs plaited straw with a grosgrain band and an elastic size regulator; it reminds me to look at trim and fit as one decision. Brixton's Joanna stays tonal with grosgrain, Lost Pattern's La Isla brings a printed green ribbon, and Gigi Burris Millinery's Samira uses wide cotton grosgrain around a conductor-cap shape.
Bits & Bows's Coastal Cowgirl lets you switch the wavy ribbon, while Eugenia Kim's Mirabel leans into an oversized pale bow. The Angela & William fedora adds an adjustable chin cord, and its Palm Braid Panama has an adjustable inner band; Hat Attack's packable bucket keeps the bow small. I would let one of these details be the color note with a white shirt or simple swimsuit cover-up. Before choosing, see whether the tie adjusts, whether the band sits at the crown rather than cutting into it, and whether the hat's size range suits you.



Joanna Short Brim Hat
Brixton

La Isla Straw Hat with Ribbon Band
Lost Pattern

Samira Straw Hat
Gigi Burris Millinery

Coastal Cowgirl Straw Scalloped Ribbon Women's Cowboy Hat
Bits & Bows

Mirabel Bow Straw Sun Hat
Eugenia Kim

Straw Fedora Sun Hat with Chin Cord
Angela & William

Palm Braid Wide Brim Panama Fedora Sun Hat with Grosgrain Band
Angela & William

Packable Raffia Bucket Hat
Hat Attack
Choose the crown, then the trim
I would choose in this order: what the brim needs to do, how the crown meets my head, then whether I want a band that blends in or makes a point. A packable bucket belongs in a travel bag; a wide brim gives the profile more presence; a boater holds its shape with a simple outfit.
Next I would check the size options or inner adjustment, then read whether the product is raffia, palm, paper or another weave. If the hat includes a cord, bow or interchangeable ribbon, decide whether it adds function or just another line. I keep returning to Reboux's 1900 Paris boater: the plaited straw did the shaping, the red trim did the punctuation.






