The Coat Check: The Best Men's Outerwear of the Season

The best men's outerwear this season falls into four groups: tailored overcoats, puffers and parkas, leather and shearling jackets, and lighter trench and field coats. Overcoats, puffers, leather and shearling jackets, and lighter trench and field coats each get a grid, so the right weight is easy to find. Match the coat to your commute and your climate, not to a mannequin.

The overcoats from Theory, Ted Baker and Cole Haan are cut to sit over a suit or a sweater. Choose wool or a wool and cashmere blend in navy, charcoal or camel. The hem should land at or just below the knee.

Puffers and parkas from Moncler, Vince and Ted Baker give the most warmth for the weight. The best ones have a clean, minimal shell that can be worn over tailoring. Check the hood and cuffs for a secure fit in wind.

Leather, shearling and suede jackets from Allsaints, A.P.C. and Ami Paris bring texture to an outfit and wear in over the years. A shorter cut works best with trousers. Keep the color dark if you want it to go with everything.

We would not buy a thin trench for real winter or a heavy parka for a mild city. Outerwear fails when it mismatches the weather.

Outerwear is the one purchase that every other outfit has to live under, so it deserves the longest fitting. Raise your arms, sit down, and check the sleeve length over a sweater. If the coat pulls anywhere or hides your hands, try the next size before settling.

If you take one thing away: buy the coat you will reach for on the coldest ordinary Tuesday, and let the statement piece be second.