In 1917 a British painter named Norman Wilkinson proposed covering ships in bold, clashing stripes and shapes. It was called dazzle paint, and the painting of real ships began that summer. By 1918 more than 2,300 British ships had been dazzled. The point was not to hide them. As the Imperial War Museum puts it, the aim was to confuse, and historians still argue about how well it worked. I love that. The most famous camouflage in history was not trying to disappear.

A good concealer is a little like that. You are not erasing your face, you are steering the eye. That is why the e.l.f. Camo Concealer works for me as a category: it is a full coverage liquid with a large doe-foot applicator that the brand says covers up blemishes and under-eye circles while delivering a boost of hydration. e.l.f. stands for Eyes Lips Face, and it was founded in 2004 in Oakland, California by Joseph Shamah and Scott Vincent Borba. The brand bought rhode in 2025, so it is no longer only the drugstore underdog.

The trick with the first grid is to pick the formula by your skin, then the shade by your undertone. The Hydrating Camo Concealer is for normal to dry skin, with sodium hyaluronate and rose water, a satin finish and a colour that dries the same as the tube. The 16HR Camo Concealer is for normal to oily skin, matte, with avocado oil and kaolin clay, and it dries darker than it looks in the tube, so give a swatch a few minutes before you decide.

Around them: the Soft Glam Satin Concealer, the Camo Color Corrector, the Soft Glam Brightening Corrector, the Camo Hydrating CC Cream SPF 30, and two tools, the Camo Concealer Sponge and the Tap & Blend Concealer Brush. The brush and sponge are what make a formula behave.

Try this: apply your base first, wait two minutes, and only then decide how much concealer you need. Most of us put concealer on skin that has not settled, and then wonder why it looks like too much.

The Soft Glam Satin Foundation is the obvious partner for the Camo concealers. If you want less, the Halo Glow Liquid Filter adds a glow, and the Halo Glow Skin Tint Mineral SPF 50 is the one for days when you want a tint and sun protection in one step. The Halo Glow Highlight Beauty Wand sits beside it for the high points of the face.

For setting, e.l.f. has a small library. The Halo Glow Setting Powder and Halo Glow Powder Filter Pressed Powder keep a little of that glow. The High Definition Powder is the loose option for a bag or a vanity, and the Set It Bright Correcting & Brightening Setting Powder is the one to try under the eyes, where brightening is the point.

A pairing I like: the 16HR Camo Concealer on the areas that need coverage, then the Halo Glow Setting Powder pressed lightly over it. You get a cover that stays and a finish that still moves.

What I would skip: a thick layer of loose powder over the Hydrating Camo Concealer under the eyes. That is where a soft satin finish turns into creases.

A habit worth borrowing: ask what you are covering before you pick a concealer. A blemish, a shadow and a scar are three different jobs, and the strongest formula is not always the right one.

Too Faced's Born This Way Super Coverage Multi-Use Concealer with Hyaluronic Acid and tarte's shape tape hydrating full coverage creamy concealer are the two with the reputations, and both name their finish in the title. NARS's Soft Matte Complete Full Coverage Longwear Concealer is the soft matte option. Huda Beauty's #FauxFilter Matte Buildable Coverage Waterproof Concealer and MAKE UP FOR EVER's HD Skin Full Cover Multi-Use Waterproof Concealer with Niacinamide are aimed at anyone who wants coverage that survives heat.

Dior's Forever Skin Correct Full-Coverage Concealer, Estée Lauder's Double Wear Stay-in-Place 24-Hour Longwear Concealer and Anastasia Beverly Hills' Magic Touch Medium to Full Coverage Concealer finish the row, and their names tell you what they are for. I would put the Double Wear next to the e.l.f. 16HR, since they are the two that promise the longest day.

A pairing I like: a full coverage formula from this row on a single spot, and the e.l.f. Hydrating Camo Concealer across the rest of the under-eye. The heavy hitter does the small job.

What I would skip: a full coverage matte concealer across the whole under-eye on a dry day. It will settle into every line.

One rule for dark circles: correct first, conceal second. A peachy or orange corrector, like the e.l.f. Camo Color Corrector from the first grid, goes on the darkest part, and a concealer goes over it. It is two thin layers, and it looks better than one thick one.

Urban Decay's Quickie 24HR Full-Coverage Waterproof Concealer and Lancôme's Teint Idole Ultra Wear All Over Hydrating Full Coverage Concealer are the two with the loudest wear claims. Fenty Beauty's We're Even Hydrating Longwear Waterproof Concealer is the one that pairs hydration with a waterproof promise, and IT Cosmetics' Bye Bye Under Eye Anti-Aging Full Coverage Concealer is made for the eye area, as the name says.

Laura Mercier's Secret Camouflage Long-wear Concealer has the word camouflage in the name, which brings this piece full circle. Bobbi Brown's Skin Hydrating Full Coverage Longwear Concealer and Pat McGrath Labs' Sublime Perfection Concealer are the polished pair, and Benefit's The POREfessional 24-Hour Blurring & Full-Coverage Natural Finish rounds out the group.

A pairing I like: the corrector under the eyes and the Hydrating Camo Concealer over it, then a little longwear formula only at the very outer corner where creasing starts.

What I would skip: piling on more concealer at lunch to fix creasing. Press it with a clean sponge first.

I think the smartest place to start is the e.l.f. formula that matches your skin. Dry under-eyes get the Hydrating Camo, oily skin gets the 16HR, and both come in a wide range of shades named by undertone, so read the names before you look at the depth.

Add the sponge, test the shade for a few minutes, and keep one stronger concealer from another brand for the days you need it. The Admiralty painted ships to confuse. You are only trying to look like you slept, and a sponge, a swatch and a few patient minutes will get you most of the way there.

If Camo feels too heavy under your eyes, I rounded up the water based concealer options I would try next.

Lipstick, blush and the rest of the bag.

French Makeup

NARS Orgasm Blush, and Every Other Way to Wear It

Red Lipstick Is Back to Being the Whole Look

Chanel Makeup

Brown Liner, Frosted Lids and Matte Skin

Brown Lipstick for Fall, From Milk Chocolate to Espresso

Rare Beauty Liquid Blush

Everyday Makeup Look