Everlane Cashmere, Denim and Dresses: The Pieces I'd Buy First

Everlane Cashmere, Denim and Dresses: The Pieces I'd Buy First

Everlane started in 2010 as a San Francisco shop built on showing what its clothes cost to make. This edit picks the cashmere, denim and dresses I would buy first.

Where Everlane started

Everlane was founded in 2010 in San Francisco by Michael Preysman and Jesse Farmer. It began as an online shop built on showing customers what a product cost to make, a habit the company called radical transparency, and its early inventory was a run of T-shirts. That plain, honest pitch is still why people open the site, so I shop it the same way, by looking for simple pieces that do one job well and skipping the rest.

The first grid is cashmere, and it is where I would start. The prices run from $68 to $131. Most are marked down from a higher listed price, so check the number on the day you buy. The Cashmere Slim Crew, Polo Sweater and Ribbed Boat-Neck are the lightest and cheapest at $68. The Boyfriend, the Boxy Crew and the Half-Zip are roomier. I would choose the Slim Crew for layering under a blazer, and the Boxy Turtleneck at $131 if you want something that works as the whole outfit.

Models in Everlane cashmere sweaters, wide-leg denim, a satin slip dress and a green turtleneck.

Denim that fits a few ways

Everlane has a lot of jeans, and the names do most of the explaining. The second grid runs from $26 to $77, and most pairs are marked down from a higher list price. The Way-High Jean 2.0 and the Selvedge Straight are the classic shapes, and the Selvedge is $57. The Column Jean at $30 is a long, straight leg in a deep brown, and the '90s Cheeky is a straight leg at $26.

If you want more volume, the Mid-Rise Trouser Jean at $42 and the OG Baggy at $44 give you room, and the Baggy Barrel-Leg at $77 curves in at the ankle. The Carpenter Jean in ecru is a work-pant style in a lighter color for spring. I would buy by inseam before anything else, since the same jean can come in several lengths. The Way-High and the Cheeky list their inseams in the product name, so read that line first, and check the rise too if you plan to tuck a top in.

Dresses for the easy days

The dress grid is the least predictable part of the site, and I like it for that reason. It spans $30 to $119, and the shapes are easy to wear with whatever shoes you already own. The Column Dress in Cotton Linen and the Cozy Rib Polo Dress, both in black, are the simple everyday picks. The Seersucker Mini Wrap Dress at $30 is the cheapest and the lightest, and the Midi Dress in SoftLuxe is a loose yellow style that skims the body.

For evenings, the Bias Cut Slip Dress in Silk Charmeuse is $50, and the Knit Square-Neck Midi is a close ribbed knit in a deep blue. The Corduroy Mini Dress is a buttoned style for cooler weather, and the Cashmere Long-Sleeve Mini at $119 is the splurge of the group. I would buy the dress that you could wear twice in the same week with different shoes. A plain black style does that better than a bright one, and it takes a jacket well.

Our honest take

Everlane is a good place to buy basics and a harder place to buy anything you need to be perfect. Across these three grids the prices run from $26 to $131, and most of what I picked is marked down from its list price, so I would not wait on a style you already love. The cashmere and the denim are where the pricing makes the most sense. For dresses I would stay with the plain shapes and skip the ones that need a very specific occasion. Sizing is worth a look on each page, since the brand sells many fits. If you take one thing away: start with one cashmere sweater and one pair of jeans in a shape you already own, and add the dress only if you have somewhere to wear it.