Classy Christmas Sweaters: Fair Isle, Sequins and the Knit a Prince Made Famous

Classy Christmas Sweaters: Fair Isle, Sequins and the Knit a Prince Made Famous

I sort classy christmas sweaters into Fair Isle, sequined, burgundy, and forest green knits, with a note on where each belongs. I would choose one for the office, family table, or party, then check its texture and finish before committing.

The sweater that started on a golf course

In 1921 the Prince of Wales, the future Edward VIII, played golf at St Andrews in a Shetland Fair Isle sweater, and a cottage craft became a craze. By 1927, the sweater had moved beyond the golf course and into the fashion conversation. A century on, that patterned yoke is still what most of us picture when someone says holiday sweater, and it is where I start when choosing classy christmas sweaters.

 

The pattern has rules. Traditional Fair Isle uses no more than two colors in any one row, so the good ones look busy across a room and calm up close. The Ganni brushed alpaca Fair Isle has a soft halo to it, the one I would wear with straight jeans and a long coat to the tree lot. Ganni began in Copenhagen in 2000 as a label that made only cashmere sweaters, so knits are its first language. The Nili Lotan Isaline is quieter, pattern without a punchline. The Monse Fair Isle turtleneck comes from Laura Kim and Fernando Garcia, Oscar de la Renta alumni who launched in New York in 2015 and call their thing relaxed glamour: here, a high neck you could wear under a blazer. The Bogner Ina in multi is cashmere from a Munich house that began in 1932 importing skis and Norwegian knitwear. My tip: hold any Fair Isle up to a window. The floats inside should lie flat, not pucker the pattern.

Collage of twelve holiday sweater picks from this edit on pale studio tiles with handwritten labels

Sequin stripes, beads and metallic tassels

Anna Sui put Fair Isle on the runway at the Strand's Rare Book Room for Fall 2024, next to silver sequin pants, so cozy knit plus hard shine is not a new idea. These four do both at once, which is the right balance for classy christmas sweaters with a party on the calendar. The FRAME Ritz in cream multi is a sequined stripe, the one I would wear to a December lunch with wide cream trousers. The Simon Miller Roni has metallic tassels that move when you do, a party piece. The Anna Sui cardigan in pink is sequin-embellished wool blend, sweet with some rock and roll, her thing since her first New York show in 1991. The Bernadette Rhye in gray is sequin and bead embellished wool and cashmere, the dressiest here, made for a satin midi skirt.

 

Fitting-room test: run your palm along the inside at the wrist and neck, since sequins sewn onto knit can scratch. Most sequin pieces are dry clean only, and if the label allows washing, go inside out, bagged, cold and gentle. What I would skip: a sequin knit on a long travel day, it snags on seatbelts and bag straps.

Burgundy cashmere, pointelle and a polo collar

Baby goat cashmere is gathered once, when the kid is under a year old, and yields about 30 grams of fiber, which is why an Arch4 sweater feels as it does. For me, classy christmas sweaters do not have to sparkle: the Arch4 Jackie in burgundy is the plainest piece here and the one I would wear most, with gray flannel trousers. The Bernadette Kira cardigan in red is an embroidered pointelle knit in silk, wool and cashmere, airy in a way winter knits rarely are. Bernadette began in Antwerp in 2018 as a mother and daughter label, the mother a former Ralph Lauren buyer, and the cardigan has a vintage-shop prettiness. The Partow Greta in burgundy is wool with structure, for a tweed skirt. The Blazé Milano Highland is a wool and cashmere polo sweater, and the collar makes it read like a shirt under a coat. If solid red feels plain, a paisley jacquard cardigan brings the same depth of color with a pattern.

 

Buying test: hold the Kira to the light. Pointelle holes should be even and the embroidery should not pucker the knit. On the Highland, button the placket up and check the collar sits flat.

Forest green V necks, turtlenecks and ribbed cardigans

Ryota Iwai, the Kobe-born designer behind Auralee, showed his first collection in Tokyo for Spring-Summer 2015 and works only with materials produced in Japan. His ribbed wool and cashmere cardigan in green is the piece here I would wear most often, buttoned over a white cropped cardigan or open over a gray tee. The FRAME Everyday cashmere V neck in Forest Night is the office sweater for December, deep enough to read as a neutral with black or camel. The GWYN Peyton in green is bolder, closer to a true evergreen, and I would wear it with dark denim and gold hoops. The Frankie Shop Iria is a fuzzy turtleneck in dark green, the one for a cold walk under a long wool coat with boots and tights.

 

Fitting-room test for anything fuzzy: rub the sleeve against a dark trouser leg and see what transfers. Brushed knits shed early and then settle. Then stretch the cuff on the Auralee: a good rib springs back. What I would skip: a fuzzy turtleneck under a tight coat, the pile flattens wherever the sleeves rub.

How I would choose one for December

I would decide what the sweater has to do before I pick a color. For a family table where a pattern is expected, the Bogner Ina or the Ganni alpaca Fair Isle. For a party, the FRAME Ritz, and then I would stop at one shiny thing. For every ordinary day in between, the Arch4 Jackie in burgundy or the FRAME V neck in Forest Night, both still in rotation come February.

 

Whichever holiday sweater you land on, fold it rather than hang it, and give it a cedar block instead of mothballs. One Fair Isle was enough for the Prince of Wales at St Andrews. It is probably enough for you.