Jude makes the strongest case for shoes when the silhouette, not a logo, does the talking. I would begin with the boots: they give a wardrobe a clear line and feel like the sort of shoe that can anchor a simple coat and trousers without demanding a special occasion. The pumps and mules make a different argument, one about proportion. A heel can change how a familiar outfit sits, but only if you can walk in it for more than the photograph, so I would think about your real day before choosing height. The sandals are the most direct expression of the label's pared-back point of view; they need little styling help and can carry a plain dress or relaxed tailoring. What I like here is the range of moods within one shoe wardrobe, not the idea that every pair deserves a place in it. Start with the category you actually wear, then be honest about comfort and mileage.

If I were choosing a first pair from Jude, I would decide based on the clothes already doing the most work in my closet. Jude boots make sense if trousers and long coats are your uniform; the pumps and mules suit someone who likes a sharper finish but does not want a full formal shoe; the sandals are the easy answer when warm weather arrives. I would not buy all three categories just because a label presents them together. Shoes need to earn their space through repeat wear, and a sculptural shape can be compelling in a product photograph but less persuasive after a full day on your feet. Try the pair with your own hem lengths and walk around before deciding. My vote goes to the silhouette that makes ordinary clothes feel more deliberate, then stays comfortable enough to reach for again next week.