Loafers: The Shoe That Went From Gucci to Everyone

Loafers: The Shoe That Went From Gucci to Everyone

Loafers are the flat shoe that never needed to be explained. Gucci introduced its Horsebit loafer in 1953, and the slip-on has been the answer to almost every outfit since. This is how to choose penny, chunky or sleek, and how to wear them with socks, skirts and tailoring.

The flat that earned its place

Loafers are one of those items that arrive in your closet and never leave. Gucci introduced its Horsebit loafer in 1953, and the metal bar across the vamp became one of the most recognizable details in footwear. After a decade of sneakers with everything, the loafer is the grown-up correction. It works with suits, with jeans, with skirts, and with the white socks that suddenly feel like a signature. It says you are comfortable and also in charge.

Loafers styled editorial photo 1

Penny, chunky or sleek

There are three personalities. The classic penny loafer has a strap across the top and a modest sole. The chunky loafer, like the ones from Tory Burch, has a lug sole and a little more attitude. The sleek loafer, from Saint Laurent or Stuart Weitzman, sits low and slim, with a pointed or almond toe. For your first pair, choose the penny, in black or deep brown. rag & bone and Sam Edelman both do versions you can wear for a decade. Chunky soles are good for rainy weather and long walks.

Loafers styled editorial photo 2

Break them in on purpose

Leather loafers are a little stiff at first, and that is normal. Wear them around the house with thick socks for a few evenings before you take them out. Look for a leather lining and a flexible sole. A heel counter that grips your heel will stop the dreaded slip. Picture her heading to work in a gray wool trouser and a black loafer, folded white sock peeking out, coffee in hand. The shoe has already molded to her foot.

Loafers styled editorial photo 3

How to dress them

Loafers love a cropped trouser, because the ankle gets to show. A pleated midi skirt with a loafer and a thin sock feels like an old school uniform, in a good way. Straight-leg jeans with a clean hem and a loafer is the easiest outfit you will wear all year. In our fashion dreams she crosses a wet street in a trench coat and a pair of burgundy loafers, and nobody asks where she got them. Suede is lovely in dry weather, patent is better in drizzle, and a lug sole is for winter.

What I would skip

I would skip loafers with a heel higher than an inch and a half, since the shoe loses its easy charm. I would skip stiff patent leather unless you plan to walk very little. And I would skip very shiny hardware if you want a classic look. A loafer should look like it has been with you for a long time, even if you bought it last week.