Nine West Pumps, Flats and Loafers: The Pairs I'd Buy First

Nine West Pumps, Flats and Loafers: The Pairs I'd Buy First

Nine West started in 1977 as a New York shoe company built on fashionable styles at popular prices. This edit picks the pumps, flats and loafers I would buy first.

A New York shoe address

Nine West began in May 1977, when Jerome Fisher and Vince Camuto started a wholesale women's shoe business called Fisher Camuto, with production in Brazil and design in New York. The company became Nine West Group in 1991, named after the address of its first Manhattan headquarters. The idea behind it was simple and has aged well: fashionable shoes at popular prices.

That is the logic I would use to shop it now. The first grid is the polished end, with pumps and slingbacks from $64.99 to $99.99. The Galora, Palomma, Ellite and Pearla are slingbacks, while the Gemmha, Tatiana and Farella are pointed pumps, so you can choose between a strap that keeps the shoe on and a clean open line. Several are in unusual finishes, including a check and a plaid, and I would treat those as one-outfit shoes. The plain slingbacks are the better first buy. Look at the heel height listed on each page before you commit, since a pump you cannot walk in is a pump you will not wear.

Collage of Nine West campaign looks: tartan pumps with a red bow, holiday party heels, a croc-embossed tote and a black shoulder bag.

Flats for the long day

The second grid is where Nine West is easiest to recommend, because the prices are low and the shapes are familiar. Everything here costs between $39.60 and $69.99. The Dippy and Burnne ballet flats are the lightest options, with woven or cut-out finishes that suit warm weather. The Kebba, Vancee, Katrel and Halie are Mary Janes, and the strap helps the shoe stay on when you are walking quickly. The Valore and Smooch are the classic ballet flats, with a plaid and a suede finish.

I would choose by sole and by finish. A very thin flat looks beautiful and feels it after a mile, so if your day includes a lot of walking, keep these for the office and the car. A woven or mesh flat will not take rain well, and a suede flat will not take it at all. If you want one pair to wear most days, the Kebba Mary Jane is the most versatile in the grid, because a black shoe with a small buckle goes with almost everything in a wardrobe.

Loafers and mules with some weight

The last grid is the one that surprised me. Nine West has a strong loafer range, and it runs from $39.99 to $79.99. The Garren and Kerisa have lug soles, which give the loafer more height and more grip on wet pavement. The Gersen and Berg are the more polished pair, with a tassel on one and a clean penny shape on the other. The Manner and Rasco are the quiet ones, in pony hair and suede, and the two Mavey mules add a knot at the front for a softer, slip-on look.

My rule with a loafer is to try it with the trousers you wear most often. A chunky sole can make a narrow trouser look unbalanced, and a flat sole can disappear under a wide leg. A mule is a different decision altogether, because it asks your foot to grip as you walk and it has no back. I would buy one only if I knew I would wear it for short days.

Our honest take

Nine West is not a brand for investment shoes, and I would not pretend otherwise. It is a brand for shoes you wear and replace, at prices that make that sensible. Across these three grids the range is $39.60 to $99.99, and the best value sits in the flats and the loafers, not the novelty pumps. I would skip the checks and plaids unless you already have the outfit for them. The black slingback, the Kebba Mary Jane and a lug-sole loafer would cover a working week between them. If you take one thing away: choose the pair that matches the shoe you reach for most already, check the sole before the style, and let the second pair be the one with a bit of personality.