This Poncho shirts edit covers the Original fishing shirts, western pearl snaps, flannels and corduroys, plus other makers worth knowing. I would start with a long-sleeve in a dark color and build from there.

Poncho Shirts: The Austin Fishing Shirt That Went Western
This Poncho shirts edit covers the Original fishing shirts, western pearl snaps, flannels and corduroys, plus other makers worth knowing
Poncho shirts and the fishing shirt that started them
Poncho launched in Austin in 2018 with one shirt, the Original, a fishing shirt that founder Clay Spencer had been picturing since his days guiding fishing trips in Alaska. His complaint was simple: the shirts on offer fit like parachutes and were full of loops and straps that did nothing. So he built one with everything you need and nothing you don't.
That is the thread through every one of the Poncho shirts here. The name is a quiet nod to St. Francis of Assisi, whose nickname in Spanish is Pancho, with an "a" traded for an "o". Add UPF 50 sun protection built into the fabric, a lens cloth tucked inside every shirt, and hidden magnets in the pockets, and you get a brand that has thought about the boring details most shirts ignore. There are at least 250 of them now, each with its own name.
Start with the Original line. The Captain in navy and The Salty Dog in white are the short-sleeve fishing shirts, and I would wear either one open over a tee on a mild October afternoon by the water. The Roaring Fork and The Gunnison, both in olive, are the ones I would hand to a friend who says he does not own anything green. The Iceman in white is the long-sleeve to roll up and forget about, and The Burnt End in black is the one that looks closest to a regular dress shirt.
The practical test: look at the pockets and the fabric together. A performance shirt should hang loose from the shoulder and still not billow, so check the fit in the slim or regular cut before you decide, and keep dark colors like The Black Smoke for evenings when you want it to read as a proper button-down.

Poncho Original performance shirts
Pearl snaps without the stiffness
Spencer has said the innovation was making a performance Western shirt, something he says he had never seen before. That idea is the whole reason this second set works: pearl snaps and yokes on the same lightweight fabric as the fishing shirts, so a cowboy shirt that does not cling when it is hot.
The Bandera in black and The Del Rio in white are the short-sleeve pair, and I would put them under a denim jacket with dark jeans for a fall night out. The Odessa in white and The Piedras Negras in black are the long-sleeve versions, which suit a belt and boots better. The Brazos in olive has a yoke you can see from across the room, so I would leave it alone and let it carry the outfit. The Del Mar in navy and The Laredo in light gray are the quiet ones for people who like the idea of snaps but not the attention.
The fitting-room test: snap the shirt closed and lift both arms. If the front rides up or the cuff pulls past the wrist, go up a size or switch to the slim cut. Run a thumb over a snap too, it should close with a clean click, not a stutter.
What I would skip: The Sabine in short sleeve if the weather is already cold. It is built for hot days, so wait for spring or layer it under something heavy.

Flannel and corduroy for colder weekends
The flannel and the corduroy are where Poncho stops being a fishing brand and starts being a fall wardrobe. The flannel is medium-weight with four-way stretch, which is not what you expect from a plaid shirt, and the corduroy has the worn-in look of an old western shirt without the stiffness.
Among the flannels, The Blue Goose in navy and teal plaid and The Black Canyon in black tonal plaid are the two I would put on first for a weekend away. The Snowcat in cream and tan is softer, and The Blue Bison in sky blue plaid is the one that works with chinos on a Monday. They have chest pockets, and the brand fits magnets into the pockets of most of its flannels, which makes grabbing a phone with one hand easy.
The corduroys are all long-sleeve western shirts with snap flap pockets. The Barton Springs in dark teal and The Zilker in olive are named for Austin landmarks, and The Red Bud in rust and The Enfield in mustard are the louder pair. I would wear The Red Bud over a white tee with dark denim and nothing else.
Test the weight before buying: hold the fabric up to the light. Flannel should look dense and the corduroy ribs should be even, with no thin patches near the cuffs.
What I would skip: layering a corduroy shirt under a heavy coat on a warm day. It will trap heat.
Fishing shirts from other makers
Other fishing shirts are worth knowing about, especially if you like the idea of a shirt that dries fast but want a different cut or a different color. Sun protection ratings vary a lot between them, so read the tag: the Howler Brothers Emerger Tech is rated UPF 35, the Huk Tide Point is UPF 30+, and Marmot's AirExchange SolarShield carries UPF protection too.
The Howler Brothers Emerger Tech in Fog Green and in Stormy Sea is a very light long-sleeve, and I would pick it for travel because it packs flat. The Huk Tide Point in Sharkskin Heather is a ripstop shirt with flap pockets, and the Huk Kona in Reefline is a bright short-sleeve for the dock. L.L.Bean's Tropicwear plaid has vented pockets and roll-up sleeve tabs, and the CoolPro in sage green is a calmer pick. The Dark Seas Costa UV Stripe in Aloe has a vented back, and the Marmot plaid in Nautical Blue is the one with a proper point collar.
Do the roll test: tab the sleeve up and see if it stays. Then reach forward as if casting, and check the back vent opens.
What I would skip: the brightest short-sleeve if you plan to wear it to dinner after. A muted stripe or sage reads much better indoors.

Emerger Tech Longsleeve Fog Green
Howler Brothers

Emerger Tech Longsleeve Stormy Sea
Howler Brothers

Tide Point Heathered Ripstop Button-Down
Huk

Kona Button-Down Reefline
Huk

Men's Tropicwear Shirt, Plaid Long-Sleeve
L.L.Bean

Men's Tropicwear CoolPro Fishing Shirt, Long-Sleeve
L.L.Bean

Costa UV Stripe Button-Up Shirt
Dark Seas

AirExchange SolarShield UPF Short Sleeve Button-Up Shirt
Marmot
Western snap shirts, other brands
Western shirts have a long list of makers, and the details are what separate them. Look at the yoke, the pocket shape and the snaps before you look at the brand name.
Howler Brothers makes two: the Broncbuster in Moonless Night has vintage yokes, contrast piping and smiley pockets, while the Dust Up in Bolan Classic Wash is a straight cotton denim snapshirt. Pendleton's Dillon in Washed Berry is cotton twill that is faded and rumpled, and the Laramie in Cowboy Blue is a short-sleeve with a rodeo heritage print. Lucky Brand's Sawtooth in faded black denim has glossy snaps and works untucked. AG's Huston in black has curved yokes and is the one I would wear to a dinner. Tecovas has two as well: the pale denim pearl snap with its Flying-T detailing, and the bronze Texas Weight corduroy with scalloped pockets.
The buying test: check that the snaps line up flat across the placket with the shirt buttoned to the collar. Misaligned snaps tell you the front hangs wrong. Wash denim once before judging the fit, because it moves.
What I would skip: wearing the bronze corduroy and the pale denim together. Pick one texture and keep the rest plain.

Broncbuster Longsleeve Snapshirt Moonless Night
Howler Brothers

Dust Up Denim Snapshirt Bolan Classic Wash
Howler Brothers

Dillon Cotton Twill Snap-Up Western Shirt
Pendleton

Sawtooth Denim Snap-Up Western Shirt
Lucky Brand

Huston Classic Fit Western Snap-Up Shirt
AG

Laramie Short Sleeve Snap-Up Western Shirt
Pendleton

Men's Denim Long Sleeve Pearl Snap
Tecovas

Men's Texas Weight Corduroy Pearl Snap
Tecovas
How I would build a Poncho shirt rotation
I would begin with a long-sleeve Original in a dark color, because it does the most work. The Gunnison or The Iceman covers the lake, a desk and an October dinner, and the lens cloth inside is one less thing to carry.
Then I would add one western snap shirt, probably The Piedras Negras in black, and one flannel for when it turns properly cold. Check the fit with your arms raised, and read the sun rating on any shirt that is not Poncho.
In 2018 Spencer wanted a shirt with everything you need and nothing you don't. That is still a good test for the rest of the closet.






























